The Sourcies are a series of fan voted awards on The CW Source. The voting takes place during the summer hiatus.
- Supernatural won 7 Sourcies:
- Hottest Moment: Sam and Madison's sex scene.
- Best Trigger Moment: Dean shoots the YED.
- Best Dream Sequence: Wish Verse in 2.20 What Is and What Should Never Be.
- Most Heartwrenching Sacrifice: Dean's Deal.
- Worst Enemy: The YED.
- Best Fight Sequence: Sam vs. Gordon.
- Best Brother-to-Brother Argument: Sam and Dean in 2.10 Hunted.
- Supernatural won 9 Sourcies:
- Best Special Effects: Sam and Madison's sex scene.
- Best First-Time Hookup: Bela in 3.10 Dream a Little Dream of Me.
- Best Lovers Reunion: Dean and Lisa in 3.02 The Kids Are Alright.
- Favorite Return Appearances: Bobby etc.
- Best (worst) Villain: Lilith.
- Best Cliffhanger: 3.16 No Rest for the Wicked.
- Best Brother Moments: Sam and Dean.
- Best Slapstick: 3.11 Mystery Spot.
- Men In Suits: Sam and Dean.
- Supernatural won 18 Sourcies:
- Best Newcomer: Castiel
- Best Fight: Sam vs. Dean in 4.21 When the Levee Breaks
- Best Friends Forever: Sam and Dean
- Best Finally! It’s About Time! Moment: Sam and Dean killing Ruby in 4.22 Lucifer Rising
- Best Special Episode: 4.05 Monster Movie
- Best Villain: Alastair
- Funniest Moment: Dean’s scream in 4.06 Yellow Fever
- Most Unexpected Hookup: Sam and Ruby
- Favorite Recurring Character: Bobby Singer
- Best Kiss: Dean and Jamie in 4.05 Monster Movie
- Biggest Family Drama: Mary’s deal with Azazel.
- Best Hair: Sam.
- Most Heartbreaking Moment: Sam and Dean’s fight in 4.21 When the Levee Breaks.
- Biggest WTF?! Moment: Sam drinking demon blood in 4.16 On the Head of a Pin.
- I Love to Hate You: Ruby.
- Most Dramatic Meltdown: Sam’s demon blood detox in 4.21 When the Levee Breaks.
- The Voice of Wisdom: Bobby Singer.
- Best Cliffhanger: 4.22 Lucifer Rising.