Reviews

This page lists some of the notable reviews and significant mentions of Supernatural.

2005

Reviews of the Pilot

• Dark Horizons

2007

• Top 50 shows of 2008 by futoncritic

2008

• The best shows of 2008 in the Chicago Tribune
• Jayne Nelson, SFX Columnist chose Supernatural as one of 2008 Top 3 TV Shows of the Year, and “Lazurus Rising” as as one of 2008 Top 3 Episodes of the Year. For the rest of the list, click here.
• Top shows of 2008 by Buddy Tv reviewers: John Kubiceks and Debbie Chang
• TV Guide's Best Shows of 2008
• Top 50 TV episodes of 2008 by futoncritic
• EWs Ken Tucker is converted to Supernatural

2009

• Overlooked and Underrated on Ugo Tv Blog

Supernatural makes the Top TV Shows for 2009 for:

• Top Tv Shows of 2009 for Maureen Ryan of Chicago Tribune
• Top Tv Shows of 2009 by The Huffington Post's Ed Martin and
• Mike Hale in the New York Times
• Best 50 episodes of 2009 TV by Buddy TV
• Favorite Episodes of TV in 2009 on Staying In (5.08 Changing Channels)
• 45 Indelible moments on TV in 2009 by avclub.com (Sam and Dean discover Wincest in 4.18 The Monster At The End Of This Book