|Dates||???? - 2015 (killed by Reese)|
|Occupation||Zanna / Imaginary Friend|
|Episode(s)||11.08 Just My Imagination|
Nicky is playing in the pool in the backyard with Zoe. After the child leaves, Reese quietly sneaks up and brutally stabs her in the pool. Sam, Dean and Sully discover her body and bury her to spare Zoe the trauma of finding her.
- Nicky was named after Supernatural writer Nicole Snyder.