- In the E!Online CW Awards Supernatural won in the Best Series category, with 38.4% of the vote. Jensen Ackles won the Best Actor category, with 41.3% of the vote, and the series creator Eric Kripke won the Best Writer/Producer/Auteur category, with 38.6% of the vote.
- In the TV.com awards for 2008, Supernatural won Best in Genre - Science Fiction, with 49% of the vote. The series lost in the Best Episode category to Lost, after being nominated for 4.03 In the Beginning.
- SFX magazine awards: Sueprnatural won best TV Show and came second for best individual episode for 4.12 Criss Angel Is a Douchebag.
- - Misha acknowledges win by Supernatural of Best Show in SFX magazine