Items in the Lock-up
- Sam's 1995 Division Championship Soccer trophy.
- Curse boxes
- Rabbit's foot
- A coffin draped in a flag.
- Michael's Sword - At first, Dean believes that "Michael's Sword" is somewhere in John's lock-up, but Zachariah later reveals that Dean himself is the angelic weapon, Michael's vessel.
- Files on various hunts John has been on.
- The first sawed-off shotgun Dean ever made (in 6th grade).
- Claymore landmines
- Fragmentation grenades
- Flashbang grenades
- Tear gas grenades
- Hunting knives
A call comes to John's cell phone, which Dean has kept charged. The caller informs them that there has been break-in at a storage locker belonging to "Edgar Cayce." Sam and Dean investigate, and find the storage area guarded against demons with a devil's trap, and a trip wire which fires a rifle propped up on a warthog's skull. Someone has broken in and been hit by the shotgun; blood is on the floor.
Zachariah lures Dean and Sam to the lock-up by implanting a fake vision in Chuck's head. Chuck then sends one of his fans, Becky Rosen, out to tell Sam and Dean about his vision, that the "angels have lost the Michael Sword" and that it is to be found "in a castle, on a hill made of 42 dogs." Dean recognizes this as a reference to the lock-up, located at Castle Storage, 42 Rover Hill. The brothers make their way there, and find dead demons and Zachariah inside. The angel tries to coerce Dean into becoming the Michael's vessel, his "sword," but Castiel intervenes, killing the other two angels and forcing Zachariah to heal Sam and Dean and leave. Castiel then brands Sam and Dean's ribs with Enochian sigils to hide them from both angels and demons and leaves.
Following a clue in John's Journal, Dean and Crowley visit the lock-up looking for information on a case that John worked where he exorcised a demon who worked for Abaddon and knew about the First Blade. Dean finds a file on the case which reveals that John did hunt a demon who mentioned that with a hunter named Tara. Dean and Crowley then leave to find Tara.