|Dates||Before humanity - 2015 (killed by Castiel)|
|Episode(s)|| 11.01 Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire|
11.02 Form and Void
Efram along with Jonah appear before Castiel sometime after he prayed for help from the other angels. The two place him in handcuffs and take him at knife point to an abandoned building, where they reveal they are not taking him to Heaven and proceed to string him up and put a bag over his head.