Up to episode 12.02, there are 33 chest sightings of Sam, Dean and Castiel. The writers of Supernatural seem to aim for equality between the brothers. So far we have enjoyed 14 wonderful chest sightings of Sam and 11 of Dean. Castiel, who showed his chest for the first time in 5.18 is catching up, with his 8 sightings. We also had the pleasure of experiencing Cupid's and Prometheus’s hairy chests. At the bottom of this page, the numbers are presented in a #Table of Chest Sightings, for easy overview.
Both Dean and Castiel are consistent in the smoothness of their chest. Sam is not. Through the seasons, the amount of chest hair on Sam’s well sculpted chest is changing. In episodes 1.17, 3.11, 5.03 and possibly 4.09 Sam’s chest is smooth and hairless. In episode 2.17 he is hairless, except for a few strands around his nipple. In episodes 6.03, 6.09, 8.10 and 9.10 his chest is clearly hairy and in 6.03 you even see a very inviting Treasure Trail.
There can be a few explanations to theses inconsistencies; most likely Sam either waxed his chest for the first seasons, and later on stopped doing it, or the hairiness increased as Sam grew older. The change in Sam’s chest hairiness coincides with pictures of Jared Padalecki from the early years of the series, compared to the famous pictures (Yeah, that one on the right – enjoy) of him on a Rio beach.
Whether you like chest hair, or no chest hair, is a matter of personal taste. To aid you, in case of any uncertainties, this is a summary of the appearances and evolution of chest hair, or no chest hair, in Supernatural. Painstakingly all bare chest appearances of the main characters, and a few more, have been studied in depth, repeatedly.
|Ghostfacers, it is also the first time we get to see Sam’s magnificent chest; all wet, muscular and glistening from the shower he just took. It is a clear shot of Sam’s shiny and very smooth chest and there is no trace of any hair (or tattoos).|
|Madison (who later suffers from Sam’s Peen of Death), we get another excellent chest view of Sam. At first look, his chest seems hairless, but if you look closer, which of course is important to do, you can actually see some hairs around his nipple.|
|Anti-possession tattoos for the first time and we get to see a tiny amount of skin again, however it is not enough to determine whether there is any chest hair on either of their muscular chests.|
|) muscles hairless, his lower abdominal is also clear of any “Treasure Trail”  .|
Sam sure knows how to have fun with a demon. While this chest sighting is not the clearest concerning chest hair, it sure is steaming hot and well worth the effort. After extensive research, Sam seems to be hairless in this episode.However, due to the difficulties to actually see the significant parts of Sam’s body, a recommendation is to watch this particular scene to form your own opinion.
|Castiel's Handprint, but we never get to see a clear chest shot. There is some armpit hair shown, but never any chest hair.|
|Carver Edlund books, and we get another partial sightings of their pectorals. Again, this is not enough skin to determine whether there is any chest hair of either of their chests.|
|Jess in his bed. We can see Sam’s chest, but who knows what he wears, or not wears, under that cover. Yet again it is evident that Sam has no chest hair.|
|Cupid shows up hugs everyone, and reviles a full on (though modestly) hairy chest.|
This is one of the most bare chested episodes in the entire series, which is greatly appreciated, and demanded an in depth study. First we get to see a partial chest shot of Dean, when he dreams that he is in bed with Lisa. Yet again the visible parts are completely hairless.The next scene is probably one of the most appreciated ones, with Sam doing bare chested workout. Not only is he very sweaty and ripped, he also clearly has chest hair on his pectoral muscles as well as a “Treasure Trail”.
|Sparrow. We only get to see a partial of Sam’s chest, but it is enough to determine that he indeed has a hairy chest.|
|Amazon, and he has without a doubt, no chest hair.|
|Linda Tran that she and Kevin need to be inked up. To convince them, Sam shows his tattoo. It's way too fast to determine anything else than that Sam has a very nice tattoo.|
|Amelia, who wears his way too large shirt from yesterday. We get to enjoy his sculpted pectorals, which are adorned with moderate hairiness.|
|Prometheus who is cursed (by Zeus) to die every day. Sam and Dean meet him for the first time as a corpse in the morgue. When he rises from death, we get to see his chest, which is slightly haired on the pectorals. When the boys catch him, we get a little glimpse of his lower abdomen; it seems the lower regions are hairless, though it is difficult to be certain.|
Castiel has had a rough day and is undressing at a laundromat. In the shot he is standing in only his white boxers, while filling the machine and (after numerous re watches) it is evident that Castiel lacks chest hair. Furthermore there seems to be no Treasure Trail, though the angle of the shot might be deceptive. Still, it's well worth some "rewinding of the tape".
In this episode we are treated with three scenes of Castiel’s bare skin.
First there is the scene when Cas walks in to a Tattoo place and shows one of his famous hip bones. There is no visible Treasure Trail, but again, the angle might be deceptive.
Then Cas gets picked up by waitress/reaper April and there are a few very interesting scenes. In bed with April, after having sex for the first time (he had protection), Cas shows his torso down to the navel. There is no trace of any chest hair at all. A Treasure Trail might start under the navel, hence the existence of such hairiness or lack thereof, is inconclusive. Though we do now know that Cas has no hair around his nipples.
The final scene of a bare chested Castiel is when he is interrogated and tortured by April. Whit the shirt open, his torso down to the navel is again visible – and hairless.
|Gadreel, who is refusing to leave his vessel. The unexpected coalition of Dean, Crowley and Castiel, makes a plan of how to abolish Gadreel from Sam. Cas opens Sam’s shirt to burn of his tattoo, and we get a glimpse of his chest before and after the removal. This is the first time we see chest hair, when only the tattoo is exposed.|
|Mark of Cain. It is not possible to draw any conclusion concerning hairiness from this shot, but it is very important to study it anyway, because of reasons.|
|Gadreel finally realizes he has been duped by Metatron, and wants to help Team Free Will. After he and Cas ends up in heavens jail, he carves the Enochian sigil that makes stuff go boom! During his speech we get to see a disfigured, but beautiful chest. It seems hairless, but who knows what was under those scars.|
Dean enjoys howling at the moon, and after singing “I’m too sexy for my love” he ends up in bed, Crowley’s bed as it turns out, with the waitress Anne Marie. Demon Dean turns out to be just as hairless on the chest, as normal Dean is.Cas is not feeling so well now that his substitute grace is fading. Sam calls him while he is in bed, under a sheet, with an open robe under the cover. Later we see him open the door for Hannah, in the same open robe. He is hot and feverish, and his torso is sweaty and hairless.
The twelfth season makes a good start, with a whole lot of chest exposure already in the second episode. Sam seems to enjoy Lady Antonia Bevell’s company in bed. We later learn that this is a hallucination, created by a potion and powerful spells.Many things can be derived from this scene if you do an in depth study of it. (This is of great import) Sam still has a really magnificent chest. He is well toned, has perky nipples and a hairy chest with a very exiting treasure trail, but it should also be noted that there are no traces of any tattoos or any form of scars or wounds. (Does Dean still have the tattoo?) To conclude, this is just a pretty darn hot Winchester chest. With hair.
Ketch rests in a hotel bed, with a killer worthy man spread, while Mary gets ready for the day. It appears that there has been some adult pillow fighting between those black silk sheets, and Ketch is in no rush to leave the crime scene.
Without super sharp high-resolution pictures, it’s a bit difficult to fully examine this unique sighting of a bare Ketch chest (repeat that 10 times at a fast pace, I dare you). However, judging from this picture, it seems that this British Man of Letter does have a hairy chest. The hairiness is sparse and concentrated to the area between his pecks.
If comparisons are made to the hairiness on other Ketch areas, the level of chest hairiness seems to be natural and not groomed.
Unfortunately we are not treated with any treasure trail sightings.
Table of Chest Sightings
|1.06 Skin||X||Shapeshifter!Dean takes shirt off before shedding skin.|
|1.13 Route 666||X||Dean in bed with Cassie after sex.|
|1.17 Hell House||X||Sam comes out of shower, all wet, wearing only a towel.|
|2.01 In My Time of Dying||X||Dean's chest is visible when he gets resuscitated by the medical team.|
|2.17 Heart||X||Sam has hot sex with werewolf.|
|3.11 Mystery Spot||X||Partial of Sam's chest, when he removes bullet.|
|3.12 Jus in Bello||X||X||Partial pecs are visible when they show their anti-posession tattoos.|
|4.01 Lazarus Rising||X||Fresh out from perdition, Dean checks his body for scars in a mirror.|
|4.09 I Know What You Did Last Summer||X||Sam has super hot sex with Ruby.|
|4.10 Heaven and Hell||X||Dean has sweet angelic sex in Baby.|
|4.18 The Monster at the End of This Book||X||X||The brothers are showing their tattoos again.|
|5.03 Free to Be You and Me||X||Sam dreams he is in bed, talking to Jess.|
|5.14 My Bloody Valentine||X||Cupid is happily hugging everyone, wearing only a loincloth.|
|5.18 Point of No Return||X||Cas cuts an Angel Banishing Sigil onto his chest, to aid the Winchesters.|
|6.03 The Third Man||X||X||Dean dreams that he is in bed with Lisa, and Sam is doing some extraordinary workout.|
|6.09 Clap Your Hands If You Believe...||X||Sam has sex with hippie chick, while Dean is abducted (and probed by aliens?).|
|7.13 The Slice Girls||X||Dean has sex with an Amazon.|
|8.02 What's Up, Tiger Mommy?||X||Sam shows his tattoo to the Trans.|
|8.10 Torn and Frayed||X||The morning after, Sam is in bed, talking to Amelia.|
|8.16 Remember the Titans||X||Greek God Prometheus comes back to life in a morgue, wearing only a sheet.|
|9.01 I Think I'm Gonna Like It Here||X||Cas needs to do some laundry.|
|9.03 I'm No Angel||XXX||Cas wants a tattoo. Cas had sex with April. Cas gets tortured by April.|
|9.10 Road Trip||X||Cas burns Sam's tattoo off.|
|9.16 Blade Runners||X||Too little, way too late... but Crowley shows a little chest hair under his silk robe.|
|9.18 Meta Fiction||X||Dean takes a shower and more than the mirror gets damp.|
|9.23 Do You Believe in Miracles?||X||Gadreel carves an Enochian sigil into his chest, to blow Castiel out of jail.|
|10.01 Black||X||XX||Cas in bed with open robe. Demon!Dean in bed after sex. Cas opens door in open robe.|
|11.10 The Devil in the Details||X||Cas got a message from Amara.|
|11.17 Red Meat||X||Sam is bleeding all over his hairy abdomen.|
|12.12 Stuck in the Middle (With You)||X||Castiel is cracking up.|
|12.02 Mamma Mia||X||Sam in bed with the enemy.|
|12.17 The British Invasion||X||Ketch has been doing naughty things with Mary.|
As can be seen in the case of Sam’s chest hair evolution, changes might occur. In the table above, a great discrepancy in chest hair sightings between Sam, Dean and Castiel can be noted. To maintain the scientific validity of this study, it is of great import that the empiric data becomes more evenly distributed. Therefore the bare chest sightings of Dean and Castiel have to increase. In fact, the number of Castiel chest hair sightings is so low that a dramatic change is of utmost importance.