|Dates||????-2013 (killed by Crowley's hellhound)|
|Episode(s)||8.14 Trial and Error|
Carl is the husband of Alice Cassity. Always having a crush on Alice and realizing that she wasn't interested in him, he made after a deal with a cross-roads demon in exchange for his soul for Alice to be his wife. Before marrying Alice, he was caught having sexual intercourse with Alice's little sister, Margot by her father, Noah Cassity.
Carl introduces himself to Sam and Dean when they arrive at the farm looking for 'work'. He leaves to let Ellie sort them out. Later on in the evening Carl and his wife Alice are having a romantic dinner outside in the yard. During their conversation they are distracted by the noise of a werewolf howling and Alice, concerned about the horses, leaves to check on them.