|Dates||???? – 2020 (killed by Lucifer)|
|Occupation|| Reaper (formerly)|
|Episode(s)||15.19 Inherit the Earth|
Lucifer teleports a bound and gagged Betty into the Men of Letters Bunker, and after introducing everyone to her, proceeds to stab her with an angel blade, killing her, while reminding everyone that Betty is the first reaper to die after Billie. After a few seconds, Betty revives as the new Death. When Dean removes the gag from her mouth, Betty headbutts him before standing up and breaking the chains around her. With her new scythe in her hand, she demands Chuck's Death Book from the confused Winchesters.
Sam and Dean take Betty to the Bunker archives, but before they can enter the room with her, she denies them entry. Sometime later, Betty appears in the Bunker library and begins reading from Chuck's book, only for Lucifer to kill her and take the opened book for himself. He then reveals to everyone that it was all just a ruse set up by God to get His book. However, even though Betty opened the book for them, the Winchesters were unable to read it as the book can only be read by Death and those Death allows.
- Kimberly Sustad previously played Amanda Willer in 7.11 Adventures in Babysitting.
- In a deleted scene, the Winchesters question Betty on her allegiance and she explains that as the new Death, she inherited all of Billie, the old Death's, knowledge and she feels that Billie had a point in wanting to kill God. Betty also dismisses Lucifer as "yesterday's papers" and states that she intends to return him to the Empty once they are done.