* [[2.21 All Hell Breaks Loose: Part One]]: Dean asks Sam to get him some pie from a diner while he waits in the car. Once inside, Sam is taken by demons and transported to Cold Oak, with the other [[:Special Children|Special Children]].
* [[3.05 Bedtime Stories]]: when a young couple, Ken and Julie, are lost in the woods, they come across a sweet old lady who invites them inside her house to rest. Ken sees pie cooling on her windowsill and accepts her invitation despite Julie's reservations. Once they've eaten a fair amount of the pie, it is revealed the pie was poisoned, and the old lady kills Ken with a butcher's knife while he lays lies on the floor unable to fight her off.
* [[3.16 No Rest for the Wicked]]: when Lilith kills her host's grandfather, he literally falls face first onto a piece of pie. Some fans believe this to be a shout-out to kroki_refur's aforementioned picspam.