|Episode(s)||1.15 The Benders|
When Deputy Kathleen Hudak arrives at the Bender house looking for Sam and Alvin Jenkins, the first person she meets is Missy Bender. When asked where her mother and father are, she tells Deputy Hudak they are dead, she then begins to smile as Pa Bender sneaks up behind the deputy and knocks her out with a shovel. She is then sent to find Jared and Lee by Pa.
Later when Dean makes his way to the Bender home, she attacks Dean with a knife pinning him to a wall, and calls for Pa. Jared and Lee arrive and a fight ensues, where Dean is eventually knocked out by Pa Bender.
When Sam and Deputy Hudak escape from their cages, Pa orders Missy to stay in the house and keep an eye on Dean while he and Jared go see what happened to Lee. Dean is able to eventually free himself, and locks Missy in a closet.