|Location||Black Water Ridge, Colorado|
When Sam and Dean are in the area investigating earlier disappearances, Ranger Wilkinson mistakes them for friends of Hayley's and, on a hunch, they go to visit her. She shows them the last video Tommy sent her via cellphone before he disappeared. She also informs them that she and her younger brother, Ben Collins, have hired a guide and are heading into the hills to find Tommy the next morning.
Dean and Sam arrive in Blackwater the next morning just as Hayley, Ben, and their guide, Roy, are setting out for Tommy’s campsite. When the group reaches the campsite, they find ripped tents and damaged equipment. Later, after Roy is killed and Dean and Sam explain that it was a wendigo that took Tommy, Hayley and Dean are themselves taken by the creature. Sam and Ben follow a trail of peanut M&M’s that Dean leaves behind and they eventually find Dean, Hayley, and Tommy hanging from the ceiling of an abandoned mine. They cut them loose and escape, and Dean kills the wendigo. Hayley thanks Dean and then leaves with Tommy and Ben in the ambulance.