|Dates||???? – 2020 (killed by Garth)|
|Episode(s)||15.10 The Heroes' Journey|
Cutty was a shapeshifter who ran a monster fight club out of an abandoned warehouse in Belgrade, Minnesota, that streamed on the dark web. Cutty appeared as an unassuming bald man, and told a mocking Dean he didn't let his abilities define him. Cutty also saw himself as a sportsman, and believed that man and monster were at their best and most pure in the heat of competition.
When Sam and Dean get caught in Cutty's fight arena, he enlightens them on his philosophy on competition, telling Sam and Dean that while he can kill them, he'd rather see what the Winchesters were capable of in a stripped-down fight. He introduces them to their opponent, Maul -- a rather large vampire -- and has him take them to their "rooms" to wait for their fight later that night.
When the time for their fight comes, Cutty demands the Winchesters remove their shirts, but he is dismayed to find that they have escaped from their confinement. Unbeknownst to Cutty, Garth had snuck into the arena and placed C4 explosives all over the building. Once he and the Winchesters were safe, Garth detonated the explosives, killing Cutty and almost of all the monsters in the building.